...
Working group draft material
- Working Draft for REFEDS Baseline Expectations
- Working draft Mapping of eduGAIN SAML Profile to REFEDS Identity Federation Baseline Expectations
- Working draft Mapping of REFEDS Specifications to REFEDS Identity Federation Baseline Expectations
Comparison between different baseline approaches
Baseline Expectations of Identity Providers
...
MRPS Statement - Membership and Eligibility. Use of the MRPS is a SHOULD recommendation in the eduGAIN SAML profile.
eduGAIN Declaration: The behaviour of any Member of any Participating Federation whose Entity description is published shall continue to be bound only by the rules of that Participating Federation.
...
Required by eduGAIN:
- technical contact (eduGAIN SAML Profile).
SHOULD:
- mdui.
RECOMMENDED:
- privacy policy in CoCo.
- security contacts in Sirtfi.
...
Baseline Expectations of Service Providers
...
Required by eduGAIN:
- technical contact (eduGAIN SAML Profile).
SHOULD:
- mdui.
RECOMMENDED:
- privacy policy in CoCo.
- security contacts in Sirtfi
...
Baseline expectations progress in federations and interfederations
...
Baseline Expectations of Federation Operators
...
eduGAIN Constitution 3.1: Have an agreement defining federation membership between the Federation and its members(typically known as a Federation Policy).
eduGAIN Declaration: " It will inform the eduGAIN Operational Team promptly of any changes affecting either the validation of Entities or the process for publishing Entity descriptions."
...
eduGAIN Constitution 3.1: Provide processes for handling complaints and incidents involving their federation members.
No specific control or measure for this. Did agree to collect security contacts for federation operators and ask people to actively state they support Sirtfi. Status?
...
Mandate Sirtfi?
...
eduGAIN sets a bar for joining as defined in the Constitution and in operationalising that: https://technical.edugain.org/joining_checklist.
eduGAIN Support is using the UK federation "rules" to chase up problems with entities, but this is unofficial request to comply rather than official.
eduGAIN SAML profile sets some requirements, which are monitored by the eduGAIN validator: https://technical.edugain.org/profile_v2.
...
SAML2Int
The "UK rules": https://www.ukfederation.org.uk/fed/edugain-import-log-with-diff.txt.
Most of these rules are documented at: InCommon Interfederation Technical Policy
...
https://technical.edugain.org/joining_checklist.
https://technical.edugain.org/profile_v2.
https://www.ukfederation.org.uk/fed/edugain-import-log-with-diff.txt.
...
eduGAIN recommends Current Best Practice documents and provides tools to monitor compliance.
...