...
Included as supporting material for implementers are two documents:
...
| comment # | Line/Reference # | Proposed Change or Query | Proposer / Affiliation | Action / Decision (please leave blank) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 5.1 Required Attributes | eduPersonEntitlement is no longer listed as required attribute, whereas seamlessaccess.org just published its "Contract Language Model License Agreement 1.0" that refers to the anonymous entity category and lists the entitlement attribute. Rather confusing. Is the new consultation not aligned with seamlessaccess.org? | Thomas Lenggenhager, SWITCH | The SeamlessAccess material refers to the older entity categories. The discussion of entitlements was not complete in either document, the original entity categories or this contract language model. We recommend that all parties refer to Federated Authorization Best Practices for the best ways to handle authorization, including the use of entitlement. There must be further discussion (possibly in FIM4L) regarding the use cases and appropriate principles for authorization. No change necessary to the entity category. |
| 2 | line 76 | Inconsistency of formatting in "schacHomeOrganization". It should be monospace throughout. | Alex Stuart, Jisc | Editorial change. Will fix. |