...
| Number | Requested Action | Response |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Remove requirement for administrative contact | Implemented |
| 2 | Change the name 'provenance' to 'registration criteria' | Implemented |
| 3 | Use RFC2119 references | Implemented |
| 4 | Change wording on metadata refresh and verification to "Service Provider *claims to*" and remove reference to verification | Implemented |
| 5 | Don't use url-encoded characters for the url | Final version will be moved to the REFEDS wiki and resolve at the URL for the entity category so this won't be an issue |
| 6 | Tidy up Identity Provider / Service Provider / IdP / SP consistency | Implemented |
| 7 | Remove requirement for technical contact | Not implemented |
| 8 | Add requirement for mdui:InformationURL | Implemented |
| 9 | Internet2 proposal for a section on 'deployment considerations': https://refeds.terena.org/images/0/05/REFEDs_RandS_Comments_From_InC_TAC-2013-10-02.pdf | This has not been implemented. Most of the recommendations are good practice guidelines for doing federated access and are NOT specific to the R&S Entity Category so should be addressed elsewhere. A new section on 'attribute request' has been added to address the issues raised in this section about SP behaviour. |
| 10 | Internet2 Internet2 proposal for a section on 'normative statements': https://refeds.terena.org/images/0/05/REFEDs_RandS_Comments_From_InC_TAC-2013-10-02.pdf. | This section is only required if the the REFEDS proposal seeks to control the behaviour of ALL R&S like entity categories AND propose its own implementation of it. I would suggest that we ONLY want to seek to control the REFEDS R&S Entity Category, so this section is not needed. For discussion. |
| 11 | Use numbering for ease of reference | Implemented |
| 12 | How do we seek to control currency and appropriateness of R&S tags? | For discussion. Require FO to undertake a lightweight annual review? |
| 13 | Does 4.3.1 need revising? Clumsy at the moment, is binding reference necessary? What does support mean? | For discussion |
| 14 | Change the definition section to: Traditionally, the three dimensions of academic endeavor are: research and scholarship, instruction, and service. A candidate for the Research & Scholarship Category is a Service Provider that supports research and scholarship as an essential component. | Not implemented. |