Attendees on the call were happy that consensus had been reached on implementing a clarification and publishing R&S v1.3 subject to the minor clarifications discussed on the call.
Nicole explained that the next step was to take the new proposal to the REFEDS Steering Committee for approval.
Action items
Change text in section 7 to: "...release all required attributes in the bundle defined in Section 5 to all R&S Service Providers, either automatically or subject to user consent or notification,without administrative involvement by any party."
Change text in section 1 to: "Identity Providers may indicate support for Service Providers in this category (self-assertion is the typical approach used by this is not the only acceptable method)"
Change text in section 4.1 to: "The service enhances the research and scholarship activities of some subset of the user community."
Change text in section 4.3.3 to: "4.3.3 The Service Provider provides an mdui:DisplayName and mdui:InformationURL in metadata (an english language version xml:lang="en" is strongly recommended)."
Update the FAQ to include the following: clarity on use of both EPPN and EPTID, comments on multi-valued attributes, information that clarifies that there may be barriers (consent, absence of information in IDM systems) that means all attributes will not be delivered.
Add wording clarification "In possessing the Entity Category Attribute with the above value, a Service Provider claims that it will not use attributes for purposes that fall outside of the service definition, *as presented at the time of registration to its users and referred to in metadata.*"